Toasty's | Cheese Lover's Only

Logo Image

  (941)564-6482

Logo Image
Image
OUR MENU(ORDER ONLINE)

FOR CHEESE LOVERS EVERYWHERE!

🥳 JOIN OUR VIP CLUB!

👇NOW AVAILABLE!👇 

JOIN NOW!

Buy-1 Get-1 Any Menu Item of Equal or Lesser Value on Your Next Visit!

Our Menu

⭐️ LOCAL FAVORITES ⭐️

Image

✅ SOUTHWEST CHICKEN MAC


Your choice of tender grilled chicken or crispy fried chicken tossed into creamy cheese sauce with pepper jack, fresh avocado, tomato, and crispy onions, finished with a bold southwest ranch drizzle for a rich, flavor-packed bite.

$14.95

Image

✅ BUFFALO CHICKEN MELT


Your choice of juicy grilled chicken or crispy fried chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, layered with melty white American and cheddar cheese, then finished with crispy onions for the perfect balance of heat, crunch, and cheesy goodness.

$12.95

Image

✅ THE CLASSIC MAC


Cavatappi pasta smothered in our rich, creamy premium white American cheese sauce and topped with a generous layer of shredded cheddar for the ultimate comfort food — simple, satisfying, and loaded with cheesy flavor.

$7.95

CLICK TO VIEW OUR FULL MENU
Full Image

🧀

OUR STORY

At Toasty’s, we believe comfort food should do more than just fill your stomach, it should warm your soul. What started as a simple idea, taking the grilled cheese sandwich we all grew up loving and giving it a gourmet twist, has grown into a place where the community gathers to share laughs, stories, and meals that bring people together. Every sandwich we make carries a little nostalgia, a little creativity, and a whole lot of heart. 

-Mike D (Owner)

⭐️

REVIEWS

Toasty's

4.9
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
393 reviews
Write a Review
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
5 days ago
Phenomenal food… if you’re gonna have such a short menu you better deliver…. Toasty’s delivered on everything I tried from the southwest mac to the jalapeño melt, they have great quality foodPhenomenal food… if you’re gonna have such a short menu you better deliver…. Toasty’s...

Phenomenal food… if you’re gonna have such a short menu you better deliver…. Toasty’s...

★ ★ ★ ★ ★
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
5 days ago
Can't go wrong with a good grilled cheese! We've passed by a couple times and had to stop in. Came in at the perfect time. There was no way to order, Food was hot, and still a few tables available to sit inside. Staff greeted you while you walked in. The selections were awesome, and the food was delicious! We will definitely be back againCan't go wrong with a good grilled cheese! We've passed by a couple times and had to stop...

Can't go wrong with a good grilled cheese! We've passed by a couple times and had to stop...

★ ★ ★ ★ ★
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
6 days ago
This is a local small business that specializes in various types of Grilled Cheese and Melt sandwiches. The staff are very welcoming and polite and I feel like you get a decent meal for a little less than $20. I personally like their fried chicken buffalo melt myself!This is a local small business that specializes in various types of Grilled Cheese and Melt sandwiches. The staff are...

This is a local small business that specializes in various types of Grilled Cheese and Melt sandwiches. The staff are...

★ ★ ★ ★ ★
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
1 week ago
Absolutely delicious and the service was excellent! We will definitely be back!Absolutely delicious and the service was excellent! We will definitely be back!

Absolutely delicious and the service was excellent! We will definitely be back!

★ ★ ★ ★ ★
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
2 weeks ago
This was my 2nd time here. Kayden & Nick were super attentive & helpful. Jen in back in the kitchen super sweet. Food is awesome, fresh, & fast. Great prices. Will definitely be back!!! This is my 4th visit & as always NEVER disappointed , always amazed, & meet new amazing employees like PedroThis was my 2nd time here. Kayden & Nick were super attentive & helpful. Jen in back in the kitchen...

This was my 2nd time here. Kayden & Nick were super attentive & helpful. Jen in back in the kitchen...

★ ★ ★ ★ ★
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
2 weeks ago
It's a pretty small cozy building but the yellow neon light hurt my eyes a little bit but besides that, they had your food ready in 5 mins and on top of that you get big servings, I have a big stomach and I got filled off one BBQ Mac this place is delicious and filing for the mediocre pricesIt's a pretty small cozy building but the yellow neon light hurt my eyes a little bit but besides...

It's a pretty small cozy building but the yellow neon light hurt my eyes a little bit but besides...

Load More

TOASTY'S HOURS

Monday

10:30am to 10pm

Tuesday

10:30am to 10pm

Wednesday

10:30am to 10pm

Thursday

10:30am to 10pm

Friday

10:30am to 10pm

Saturday

10:30am to 10pm

Sunday

10:30am to 10pm

📍 

OUR LOCATION

14876 Tamiami Trail
North Port, FL 34287

📞 CLICK TO CALL

(941)564-6482

WANT A BOGO

ON YOUR NEXT VISIT?

👇 JOIN OUR VIP CLUB! 👇

Image
CLICK HERE!

Join our VIP Customer Club and get a BOGO anything on our menu of equal or lesser value on your next visit!