Skip to main content
Buffalo Chicken Melt

Sandwiches in Florida

Grilled cheese and chicken sandwiches at Toasty's in Florida pair savory fillings with sauces and are available for pickup.

Order online

Sandwiches to Try

“Amazing food. I ordered both a sandwich and a Mac and cheese so I could split those with my son. Really one of the best sandwiches I've ever had. And I couldn't resist the desserts, which were also amazing.”

“Very clean place, food was amazing, I had the buffalo chicken melt I would give it 6 starts if I could, also had very friendly staff. We will most definitely be back to try other things on the menu!”

“Stumbled upon this cute little place while in town for my son’s football game. I love me some grilled cheese and tomato soup! Top 5 fav for sure… and boy this place did NOT disappoint. The soup was SO flavorful, and the gc had the perfect crisp and FRESHEST cheese . Go get yourself some 🤤”

“Finally made it to the new Toasty’s in North Port and it was delicious! Our food came quick and piping hot. I had the jalepeno pepper jack melt and it was incredible. Very large melt. What a fantastic new and different addition to our town. Bravo!”

From the Kitchen at Toasty's

Toasty's sandwiches range from chicken-filled melts to shredded pot roast on buttery High Crown white bread. Classic Grilled Cheese pairs premium white American with sharp cheddar, griddled between hefty slices.

Buffalo Chicken Melt has buffalo sauce and a ranch drizzle; Jalapeño Pepper Jack Melt adds crunchy jalapeños and crispy onions. California Melt combines chicken, bacon, avocado and tomatoes.

Order in Florida for pickup, dine-in or delivery. Deep Fried PBJ is battered and fried until golden, then dusted with powdered sugar and served with chocolate dipping sauce; you can choose strawberry jelly.

Frequently asked questions

What are your most popular sandwiches options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

  • Buffalo Chicken Melt — Choose grilled or fried chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, with white American, cheddar, crispy onions, and ranch on High Crown white bread.
  • BBQ Chicken Melt — This grilled cheese sandwich has BBQ-coated chicken, white American and cheddar cheeses, and crispy onions between slices of buttery white bread.
  • Classic Melt — This classic melt uses hefty High Crown white bread, with optional add-ons including bacon, chicken, avocado, and tomato.
  • Pot Roast Melt — Tender shredded pot roast is grilled with white American and pepper jack cheeses, crispy onions, Parmesan, and buttered High Crown white bread.
  • Southwest Chicken Melt — This grilled cheese sandwich combines chicken, white American and pepper jack cheeses, avocado, tomato, crispy onions, and southwest ranch on buttery white bread.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for sandwiches throughout the Florida area. Order your sandwiches online for convenient pickup or delivery.

Is there a kids menu?

Toasty's offers kid-friendly options, including Small Classic Mac & Cheese and Half Classic Melt.

Explore our menu to see all the options for your next family meal.