Skip to main
Toasty's
  • PopularCurrent Category
  • Macs
  • Melts
  • Sides & Desserts
  • Kids Menu
  • Drinks

Toasty's Sarasota

2300 Bee Ridge Rd #301, Sarasota, FL

2300 Bee Ridge Rd #301, Sarasota, FL

·

  • PopularCurrent Category
  • Macs
  • Melts
  • Sides & Desserts
  • Kids Menu
  • Drinks

Popular

  • Classic Mac.

    Classic Mac

    $7.95

  • Funnel Cake Fries.

    Funnel Cake Fries

    $5.95

  • Southwest Chicken Mac.

    Southwest Chicken Mac

    $14.95

  • Buffalo Chicken Mac.

    Buffalo Chicken Mac

    $12.95

  • Pot Roast Melt.

    Pot Roast Melt

    $14.95

  • California Melt.

    California Melt

    $14.95

  • Deep Fried PB&J.

    Deep Fried PB&J

    $2.95

  • Classic Melt.

    Classic Melt

    $7.95


Macs

Cavatappi mac and cheese smothered in our premium white American cheese sauce.

Classic Mac

Cavatappi pasta smothered in our premium white American cheese sauce and topped with a generous layer of shredded cheddar.

$7.95

Classic Mac.

Pot Roast Mac

Cavatappi in premium white American cheese sauce loaded with tender Fontanini shredded pot roast, pepper jack, crispy onions and grated parmesan.

$14.95

Pot Roast Mac.

Buffalo Chicken Mac

Cavatappi in premium white American cheese sauce with grilled or fried chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, cheddar cheese, crispy onions and a ranch drizzle.

$12.95

Buffalo Chicken Mac.

BBQ Mac

Mac and cheese with grilled or fried chicken tossed in BBQ sauce, folded into our premium white American cheese sauce over cavatappi, topped with cheddar cheese and crispy onions.

$12.95

BBQ Mac.

Jalapeño Pepper Jack Mac

Cavatappi in premium white American cheese sauce with pepper jack, crunchy jalapeños and crispy onions, finished with a jalapeño drizzle for a creamy, spicy kick.

$12.95

Jalapeño Pepper Jack Mac.

California Mac

Cavatappi in premium white American cheese sauce with grilled or fried chicken, bacon, fresh avocado, tomatoes, cheddar cheese and a ranch drizzle.

$14.95

California Mac.

Southwest Chicken Mac

Cavatappi in premium white American cheese sauce with grilled or fried chicken, pepper jack, fresh avocado, tomato and crispy onions, finished with a bold southwest ranch drizzle.

$14.95

Southwest Chicken Mac.

Melts

Gourmet grilled cheese on buttery High Crown white bread.

Classic Melt

Premium white American and sharp cheddar griddled between hefty, buttered High Crown white bread, the gourmet grilled cheese that started it all.

$7.95

Classic Melt.

Pot Roast Melt

Grilled cheese melt on buttery High Crown white bread with tender Fontanini shredded pot roast, premium white American cheese, pepper jack, crispy onions and grated parmesan.

$14.95

Pot Roast Melt.

Buffalo Chicken Melt

Grilled cheese melt on buttery High Crown white bread with grilled or fried chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, premium white American and cheddar, crispy onions and a ranch drizzle.

$12.95

Buffalo Chicken Melt.

BBQ Chicken Melt

Grilled cheese melt on buttery High Crown white bread with grilled or fried chicken tossed in BBQ sauce, premium white American and cheddar, and crispy onions.

$12.95

BBQ Chicken Melt.

Jalapeño Pepper Jack Melt

Grilled cheese melt on buttery High Crown white bread with premium white American cheese, pepper jack, crunchy jalapeños and crispy onions, finished with a jalapeño drizzle.

$12.95

Jalapeño Pepper Jack Melt.

California Melt

Grilled cheese melt on buttery High Crown white bread with grilled or fried chicken, bacon, fresh avocado, tomatoes, premium white American and cheddar, and a ranch drizzle.

$14.95

California Melt.

Southwest Chicken Melt

Grilled cheese melt on buttery High Crown white bread with grilled or fried chicken, premium white American cheese, pepper jack, fresh avocado, tomato and crispy onions, finished with a southwest ranch drizzle.

$14.95

Southwest Chicken Melt.

Sides & Desserts

Fries

Crispy golden fries, lightly salted. Choose small or large, large is great for sharing.

$2.95+

Fries.

Fresh Garden Salad

Fresh chopped iceberg and romaine blend with tomatoes, carrots, radish, red cabbage, crispy onions, premium American cheese and your choice of dressing.

$7.95

Fresh Garden Salad.

Deep Fried PB&J

A peanut butter and jelly sandwich battered and deep fried until golden, dusted with powdered sugar and served with chocolate dipping sauce. Choose your jelly.

$2.95

Deep Fried PB&J.

Funnel Cake Fries

Fried-dough funnel cake strips dusted with powdered sugar and served with chocolate and caramel dipping sauces.

$5.95

Funnel Cake Fries.

Side Sauce

$0.00

Tomato Soup

Rich, creamy house tomato soup, the perfect companion for dunking a melt. Available as a cup or a bowl.

$1.95+

Side of Premium Cheese Sauce

A side cup of our premium white American cheese sauce for dipping.

$0.95


Kids Menu

Kids Half Classic Melt

A kid-sized grilled cheese, premium white American and cheddar griddled on buttery High Crown white bread.

$3.95

Kids Half Classic Melt.

Kids Small Classic Mac & Cheese

A kid-sized bowl of cavatappi in our premium white American cheese sauce topped with shredded cheddar.

$3.95

Kids Small Classic Mac & Cheese.

Drinks

Bottled Water

Chilled bottled water.

$1.95

Bottled Water.

Apple Juice

Sweet, chilled apple juice.

$1.95

Apple Juice.

Powerade

A bottle of Powerade sports drink.

$3.95

Powerade.

Bottled Coke

Classic Coca-Cola in a bottle.

$3.45

Bottled Coke.

Hank's Orange Cream Soda

Hank's Gourmet orange cream soda in a glass bottle.

$3.45

Hank's Orange Cream Soda.

Hank's Vanilla Cream Soda

Hank's Gourmet vanilla cream soda in a glass bottle.

$3.45

Hank's Vanilla Cream Soda.

Hank's Root Beer

Hank's Gourmet root beer in a glass bottle.

$3.45

Hank's Root Beer.

Hank's Black Cherry Soda

Hank's Gourmet black cherry soda in a glass bottle.

$3.45

Hank's Black Cherry Soda.

Service fee

Our online provider charges a 5% service fee, up to $7.50. This helps cover costs related to your order including 24/7 support.

Sarasota
  • Menu

  • Catering

  • Our Story

  • Locations

  • Gift Cards

  • We're Hiring

Terms of serviceAccessibility

Toastys LLC 2026 All Rights Reserved

Powered by Owner