
Start with the buffalo chicken melt
Chicken, cheese and buffalo sauce on toasted bread. It's the one with the heat.
Loaded mac and cheese
Try the Buffalo chicken mac or the BBQ mac. They get the same cheesy treatment as the melts.
Tables on Tamiami Trail
Grab a table in the dining room. Mike D comes around to say hello and see how everything is.
More from the menu
Toasty's Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!
Frequently asked questions
What are you known for?
We’re known for American comfort food, including grilled cheese, chicken melts, pot roast mac and cheese, and deep-fried peanut butter and jelly sandwiches.
- American Food: American comfort food brings together grilled cheese, loaded mac and cheese, hearty melts, and deep-fried peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. Examples include Classic Grilled Cheese, BBQ Chicken Mac, Jalapeño Pepper Jack Melt, Pot Roast Mac, and Deep Fried PBJ.
- Sandwiches: Grilled cheese and melts range from classic cheese to Buffalo chicken, barbecue chicken, pot roast, and jalapeño pepper jack. Examples include Classic Grilled Cheese, Buffalo Chicken Melt, BBQ Chicken Melt, Pot Roast Melt, and Jalapeño Pepper Jack Melt.
- Chicken: Chicken comes in comforting melts and mac and cheese with barbecue, Buffalo, and Southwest flavors. Examples include BBQ Chicken Mac, Buffalo Chicken Mac, Buffalo Chicken Melt, and Southwest Chicken Melt.
- Drinks: Bottled water, apple juice, and Powerade accompany sodas in cola, root beer, orange cream, vanilla cream, and black cherry flavors. Examples include Bottle Water, Apple Juice, Powerade, Bottle Coke, Hanks Root Beer, and Hanks Orange Cream Soda.
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: Warm Mineral Springs, North Port, Tarpon Point, El Jobean, Murdock, Sarasota County, Englewood, Venice East, Port Charlotte, Woodmere, Venice Groves, Manasota, South Venice, New Point Comfort, Venice Gardens, Manasota Beach, Venice, Manasota Key, Grove City, and Punta Gorda Beach.











